By Counterforce Health Team in Gilenya (fingolimod) —

How to Get Gilenya (fingolimod) Covered by UnitedHealthcare in North Carolina: Prior Authorization Forms, Appeal Timelines, and External Review Rights

Answer Box: Getting Gilenya Covered in North Carolina

UnitedHealthcare requires prior authorization for Gilenya (fingolimod) through OptumRx, typically requiring documentation of ≥2 failed MS therapies plus baseline safety tests (EKG, eye exam, labs). North Carolina provides 72-hour step therapy exception decisions and 120-day external review rights through Smart NC after internal appeals. First step today: Have your neurologist gather prior therapy records and safety test results, then submit PA via UnitedHealthcare Provider Portal or fax to OptumRx at 1-844-403-1027.

Table of Contents

  1. Why North Carolina State Rules Matter for Your Coverage
  2. Prior Authorization Requirements and Turnaround Standards
  3. Step Therapy Protections and Medical Exceptions
  4. Continuity of Care During Plan Changes
  5. External Review and Complaint Rights
  6. Practical Scripts for Calls and Appeals
  7. Coverage Limits and ERISA Plan Differences
  8. Quick Reference: Forms and Contacts

Why North Carolina State Rules Matter for Your Coverage

North Carolina's insurance laws create minimum standards that UnitedHealthcare must follow for fully insured plans, including individual marketplace and most employer group plans. These protections don't apply to self-funded ERISA plans, but many employers voluntarily adopt similar processes.

For Gilenya specifically, North Carolina law ensures:

  • Step therapy exception decisions within 72 hours (24 hours for urgent cases)
  • External review rights through Smart NC after internal appeals fail
  • Clear appeal processes with written denial reasons and supporting documentation requirements
Note: UnitedHealthcare's OptumRx manages pharmacy benefits nationally, but North Carolina-regulated plans must comply with state timelines and appeal rights.

Prior Authorization Requirements and Turnaround Standards

Coverage at a Glance

Requirement What It Means Where to Find It Timeline
Prior Authorization Required for all Gilenya prescriptions UnitedHealthcare Provider Portal 7 days standard, 72 hours expedited
Step Therapy Must try ≥2 other MS therapies first OptumRx formulary policy Exception decision: 72 hours (NC law)
Safety Baseline EKG, eye exam, CBC/LFTs, VZV immunity FDA prescribing information Submit before first dose
Neurologist Prescription Must be prescribed by/with MS specialist UnitedHealthcare clinical criteria N/A

Documentation Requirements

Your neurologist must provide:

  1. Diagnosis confirmation: Relapsing MS with McDonald criteria documentation
  2. Prior therapy failures: At least 2 disease-modifying therapies with:
    • Drug names, doses, and duration tried
    • Specific outcomes (relapses, MRI progression, side effects)
    • Dates of treatment and discontinuation
  3. Safety monitoring plan:
    • Baseline EKG (within 30 days)
    • Comprehensive ophthalmologic exam (within 30 days)
    • Complete blood count and liver function tests
    • Varicella immunity documentation or vaccination records
Tip: Counterforce Health specializes in turning insurance denials into targeted, evidence-backed appeals by identifying the specific denial basis and drafting point-by-point rebuttals aligned to the plan's own rules.

Step Therapy Protections and Medical Exceptions

North Carolina's Proper Administration of Step Therapy Protocols law (S.B. 361) requires UnitedHealthcare to grant exceptions when:

  • Required step drugs are likely to cause adverse reactions
  • Required drugs are expected to be ineffective for the patient
  • Patient previously tried required drugs with poor outcomes
  • Patient is stable on current therapy and switching would be inappropriate

How to Request a Step Therapy Exception

Documentation phrases that help:

  • "Patient experienced disease progression on [step drug] with new T2 lesions on MRI dated [date]"
  • "Previous trial of [drug] resulted in [specific side effect] requiring discontinuation"
  • "Patient contraindicated for [step drug] due to [medical condition/drug interaction]"
  • "Patient stable on fingolimod for [duration] with no relapses and improved EDSS score"

Submit via:

  • UnitedHealthcare Provider Portal (fastest)
  • CoverMyMeds electronic PA system
  • Fax to OptumRx: 1-844-403-1027
From our advocates: We've seen step therapy exceptions approved within 24 hours when neurologists provide specific dates and outcomes from prior therapy trials, rather than general statements about "inadequate response." The key is documenting exactly why each required drug failed or is inappropriate for this specific patient.

Continuity of Care During Plan Changes

North Carolina's continuity-of-care law (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-67-88) primarily protects against provider network changes, not formulary changes. However, you can still request transition coverage if:

When Protections Apply

  • Provider leaves network: Up to 90 days transitional coverage for ongoing MS treatment
  • Plan changes: Request "transition of care" form similar to NC State Health Plan's process
  • Formulary changes: UnitedHealthcare's own transition policy (typically 30-day temporary fills)

What to Request

Call UnitedHealthcare member services and ask for:

  1. Transition coverage request form if your neurologist is going out-of-network
  2. Formulary exception if Gilenya is removed or re-tiered
  3. Temporary transition fill while exception is processed

External Review and Complaint Rights

If UnitedHealthcare denies your Gilenya coverage after internal appeals, North Carolina's Smart NC program provides independent review.

External Review Process

Timeline Action Required Contact
Within 120 days of final denial Submit external review request Smart NC online form
10 business days Smart NC preliminary review 1-855-408-1212
45 days Independent review decision Binding on UnitedHealthcare

Expedited Review for Urgent Cases

  • Available for: Progressive MS requiring immediate treatment
  • Timeline: Decision within 72 hours (sometimes 24 hours)
  • How to request: Mark "urgent" on Smart NC form and have neurologist document medical urgency

Required Documents

  • UnitedHealthcare's denial letter
  • Medical records supporting Gilenya necessity
  • Neurologist's treatment recommendation
  • Prior therapy documentation
Note: Smart NC staff provide free assistance with filing and can help gather supporting documentation. Call 1-855-408-1212 to speak with insurance experts.

Practical Scripts for Calls and Appeals

Patient Phone Script for UnitedHealthcare

"Hi, I'm calling about prior authorization for Gilenya for multiple sclerosis. My member ID is [number]. My neurologist submitted a PA request on [date]. Can you tell me the status and what additional documentation might be needed? Also, does my plan require step therapy, and if so, what are the exception criteria under North Carolina law?"

Clinic Staff Script for Peer-to-Peer Review

"I'm requesting a peer-to-peer review for [patient name] regarding Gilenya denial. The patient has relapsing MS with documented progression on [previous therapies]. We have complete safety monitoring in place and clinical justification for bypassing step therapy under North Carolina's medical exception criteria."

Medical Necessity Letter Template Points

Your neurologist should address:

  1. Clinical problem: "Patient has relapsing-remitting MS with [number] relapses in past year despite treatment"
  2. Prior treatments: "Previously failed [drug 1] due to [specific outcome] and [drug 2] due to [specific outcome]"
  3. Medical rationale: "Fingolimod is medically necessary because [patient-specific factors]"
  4. Safety compliance: "All FDA-required monitoring completed including [list tests and dates]"
  5. Urgency: "Delay in treatment risks irreversible neurological damage"

Coverage Limits and ERISA Plan Differences

What North Carolina Law Covers

  • Fully insured commercial plans (most small employers, individual/family plans)
  • State-regulated plans including marketplace/ACA plans
  • HMO plans (continuity of care protections)

What It Doesn't Cover

  • Self-funded ERISA plans (many large employers) - these follow federal law only
  • Federal employee plans (FEHB) - separate appeal process
  • Medicare Advantage/Part D - federal Medicare appeal rights apply
How to check: Look for "administered by" vs. "insured by" on your plan documents. Self-funded plans often say "administered by UnitedHealthcare" rather than "insured by."

Quick Reference: Forms and Contacts

UnitedHealthcare Contacts

  • Member Services: Number on back of ID card
  • Provider Portal: uhcprovider.com
  • OptumRx PA Fax: 1-844-403-1027
  • Expedited Review: Mark "urgent" on PA form

North Carolina Resources

  • Smart NC External Review: ncdoi.gov external review
  • Smart NC Helpline: 1-855-408-1212
  • NC Department of Insurance: Consumer assistance for plan complaints

Key Forms

  • UnitedHealthcare Prior Authorization Form (via provider portal)
  • Smart NC External Review Request Form
  • Step Therapy Exception Documentation (part of PA process)

About Counterforce Health

Counterforce Health helps patients, clinicians, and specialty pharmacies get prescription drugs approved by turning insurance denials into targeted, evidence-backed appeals. The platform identifies denial reasons and drafts point-by-point rebuttals aligned to each plan's specific criteria, pulling the right evidence from FDA labeling, peer-reviewed studies, and specialty guidelines.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does UnitedHealthcare prior authorization take in North Carolina? Standard PA decisions take up to 7 days; expedited reviews are completed within 72 hours. Under North Carolina law, step therapy exception requests must be decided within 72 hours (24 hours for urgent cases).

What if Gilenya is non-formulary on my plan? Request a formulary exception through the same PA process. Provide medical necessity documentation showing why formulary alternatives are inappropriate or have failed.

Can I get emergency fills while waiting for approval? Yes, ask your pharmacy about emergency supplies (typically 3-7 days) or request expedited review if you're at risk of relapse without medication.

Does step therapy apply if I was stable on Gilenya with a previous insurer? North Carolina law requires exceptions for patients stable on current therapy. Have your neurologist document your stability and request an exception citing "patient stable on requested drug."

What's the difference between internal appeals and external review? Internal appeals go back to UnitedHealthcare for reconsideration. External review through Smart NC uses independent medical experts and their decision is binding on the insurer.

Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes and does not constitute medical or legal advice. Coverage decisions depend on your specific plan terms and medical circumstances. For personalized assistance, contact Smart NC at 1-855-408-1212 or consult with your healthcare provider and insurance representative.

Sources & Further Reading

Powered by Counterforce Health—AI that turns drug denials into evidence-based appeals patients and clinicians can submit today.