By Counterforce Health Team in Carbaglu (carglumic acid) —

How to Get Carbaglu (Carglumic Acid) Covered by Aetna CVS Health in New York: Prior Authorization Guide and Appeals Process

Answer Box: Getting Carbaglu Covered by Aetna CVS Health in New York

Aetna CVS Health covers Carbaglu (carglumic acid) for NAGS deficiency and certain organic acidemias with prior authorization. Key requirements: confirmed diagnosis via genetic/biochemical testing and documented elevated plasma ammonia levels. If denied, New York residents can appeal internally (180 days) then request external review through the Department of Financial Services. First step today: Have your doctor submit a PA request with complete diagnostic documentation through the Aetna provider portal.

Table of Contents

Coverage Requirements at a Glance

Requirement What It Means Where to Find It Source
Prior Authorization Required Doctor must get approval before dispensing Aetna specialty drug list Aetna 2025 Specialty Drug List
Confirmed NAGS Deficiency Genetic, biochemical, or enzyme testing Medical records/lab reports Aetna PA Policy
Elevated Ammonia Documentation Baseline plasma ammonia levels Lab results before treatment Aetna PA Policy
Outpatient Use Only No inpatient coverage Policy restrictions Aetna PA Policy
12-Month Initial Approval Must reauthorize annually PA approval letter Aetna PA Policy

Step-by-Step: Fastest Path to Approval

  1. Gather Required Documentation (Patient + Doctor)
    • Genetic or biochemical test results confirming NAGS deficiency
    • Lab results showing elevated baseline ammonia levels
    • Clinical notes documenting hyperammonemia episodes
    • Insurance card and member ID
  2. Doctor Submits Prior Authorization (Doctor)
    • Submit through Aetna provider portal or fax
    • Include all diagnostic documentation
    • Expected timeline: 30-45 days for standard review
  3. Request Expedited Review if Urgent (Doctor)
    • Mark request as expedited for acute hyperammonemia
    • Decision within 72 hours for urgent cases
    • Include clinical justification for urgency
  4. Follow Up on Status (Patient or Doctor)
    • Check approval status through member portal
    • Call member services if no response within expected timeframe
    • Document all communications
  5. Fill at CVS Specialty if Approved (Patient)
    • Carbaglu must be dispensed through specialty pharmacy
    • CVS Specialty will coordinate with your doctor
    • Expect delivery within 2-3 business days
  6. If Denied, File Internal Appeal (Patient or Doctor)
    • Submit within 180 days of denial
    • Include additional supporting documentation
    • Response within 7 days for standard appeals
  7. Consider External Review if Still Denied (Patient)
    • File with New York Department of Financial Services
    • Must file within 4 months of final internal denial
    • Independent medical review with binding decision
From Our Advocates: We've seen many Carbaglu denials overturned when families provided complete genetic testing results and detailed ammonia lab trends. One family's appeal was successful after their metabolic specialist wrote a comprehensive letter explaining why no alternative therapy could replace Carbaglu's specific mechanism for NAGS deficiency. These cases highlight the importance of thorough documentation and specialist involvement.

When Alternatives Make Sense

For hyperammonemia treatment, Aetna CVS Health may suggest alternatives before approving Carbaglu. However, no direct alternatives exist for NAGS deficiency because Carbaglu is the only FDA-approved therapy that replaces deficient N-acetylglutamate.

Alternative therapies sometimes mentioned:

  • Sodium phenylbutyrate: Effective for other urea cycle disorders but not NAGS deficiency
  • Glycerol phenylbutyrate (Ravicti): Also not effective for NAGS deficiency
  • Dietary protein restriction: Used as adjunctive therapy only

When alternatives don't work: If Aetna suggests trying alternatives first, your doctor should document that these agents cannot address the underlying NAGS deficiency. The appeal should emphasize that Carbaglu has a unique mechanism of action that cannot be replicated by other ammonia-scavenging drugs.

Common Denial Reasons & How to Fix Them

Denial Reason How to Overturn Required Documentation
Diagnosis not confirmed Submit genetic/biochemical testing Enzyme assay results, genetic panel, metabolic specialist consultation
Missing ammonia levels Provide baseline lab data Plasma ammonia results before treatment initiation
Off-label use concern Clarify FDA-approved indication FDA labeling showing approval for NAGS deficiency
Step therapy required Request exception for rare disease Letter explaining no effective alternatives exist
Not medically necessary Provide clinical justification Detailed medical necessity letter from specialist

Appeals Playbook for New York

Internal Appeal Process

Timeline: 180 days from denial to file; 7 days for standard response (72 hours for expedited)

How to File:

  • Online: Aetna member portal
  • Phone: Member services number on insurance card
  • Mail: Address provided in denial letter
  • Required: Denial letter, additional medical records, appeal letter

External Review Process

New York's external review system provides an independent second opinion when Aetna denies coverage.

Eligibility:

  • Must complete internal appeal first
  • File within 4 months of final internal denial
  • Applies to medical necessity denials

Process:

  1. Request external review through New York Department of Financial Services
  2. Pay $25 fee (waived for financial hardship or Medicaid)
  3. Independent medical expert reviews case
  4. Decision is binding on Aetna

Expedited External Review:

  • Available for urgent situations
  • Decision within 72 hours (24 hours for urgent drug denials)
  • No fee for expedited reviews
Tip: New York's external review database includes past decisions with medical literature references. Search similar cases to strengthen your appeal with relevant citations.

Costs & Savings Options

Manufacturer Support:

Foundation Grants:

  • National Organization for Rare Disorders (NORD) medication assistance
  • HealthWell Foundation grants for rare diseases
  • Patient Advocate Foundation copay relief

State Programs:

  • New York State of Health premium tax credits
  • Medicaid expansion coverage for eligible individuals
  • Essential Plan for those above Medicaid limits

When Counterforce Health helps patients navigate insurance denials, we often see that comprehensive documentation makes the difference between approval and denial. Our platform helps identify exactly what evidence payers need and crafts targeted appeals that address each denial reason systematically.

FAQ: Your Top Questions Answered

How long does Aetna CVS Health prior authorization take in New York? Standard PA decisions take 30-45 days. Expedited reviews for urgent medical needs are completed within 72 hours.

What if Carbaglu is not on Aetna's formulary? Carbaglu is covered by Aetna with prior authorization. If denied, you can request a formulary exception by demonstrating medical necessity and lack of effective alternatives.

Can I get expedited approval for acute hyperammonemia? Yes. Your doctor should mark the PA request as expedited and provide clinical documentation of the urgent medical need. Decisions are made within 72 hours.

Does step therapy apply to Carbaglu in New York? Aetna may require trying alternatives first, but you can request a step therapy exception for rare diseases like NAGS deficiency where no effective alternatives exist.

What happens if I move to New York from another state while on Carbaglu? New York has continuity-of-care protections. Contact Aetna to ensure continued coverage during the transition and update your provider network.

How much does Carbaglu cost without insurance? Cash prices can exceed $200 per 200mg tablet. Monthly costs vary significantly based on weight-based dosing. Manufacturer support programs may help reduce out-of-pocket costs.

Can I appeal if Aetna requires me to use CVS Specialty Pharmacy? Most specialty medications like Carbaglu must be dispensed through designated specialty pharmacies. This is typically a plan requirement rather than a coverage denial.

What if my doctor disagrees with Aetna's denial? Your doctor can request a peer-to-peer review to discuss the case directly with an Aetna medical director. This often helps clarify clinical necessity and resolve denials.

At Counterforce Health, we understand that navigating insurance approvals for rare disease medications like Carbaglu can be overwhelming. Our platform analyzes denial letters, identifies specific payer requirements, and helps craft evidence-based appeals that significantly improve approval rates for patients and their healthcare teams.

Checklist: What to Gather Before You Start

Medical Documentation:

  • Genetic testing results confirming NAGS deficiency
  • Biochemical or enzyme assay results
  • Baseline plasma ammonia levels (before treatment)
  • Clinical notes documenting hyperammonemia episodes
  • Metabolic specialist consultation notes

Insurance Information:

  • Aetna member ID card
  • Policy details and formulary information
  • Previous denial letters (if applicable)
  • Explanation of Benefits (EOB) statements

Contact Information:

  • Prescribing physician contact details
  • CVS Specialty Pharmacy information
  • Aetna member services phone number
  • New York Department of Financial Services contact info

Sources & Further Reading

Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical or legal advice. Coverage policies and appeal procedures may change. Always verify current requirements with your insurance plan and consult your healthcare provider for medical decisions. For personalized assistance with insurance appeals and prior authorization, visit Counterforce Health.

Powered by Counterforce Health—AI that turns drug denials into evidence-based appeals patients and clinicians can submit today.